most overrated anime characters of all time

Anime, an art form with a legion of passionate enthusiasts, has a fascinatingly diverse array of characters. However, as in every realm of entertainment, there’s a ubiquitous debate over which anime figures have been undeservedly elevated to stardom. An overrated character could be one with a cool design, a substantial fanbase, or a significant role in a successful franchise. They could even be a protagonist who, despite their prominence, struggles with substantial character flaws or poor development. This article scrutinizes ten such characters who, in our view, may not entirely live up to their inflated reputation.

top most overrated anime characters of all time:

Please note: The ensuing list is subjective and does not follow any specific ranking order.

1. Natsu Dragneel – ‘Fairy Tail’

Natsu Dragneel

Natsu Dragneel, the fiery protagonist of Fairy Tail, possesses all the traits of an exciting hero. Despite this, his character arc has been mired by poor development, formulaic fight scenes, and an overreliance on external factors such as luck or friends for victories. These aspects have led to a sense of disenchantment among fans, making Natsu one of the more overrated anime characters.

2. Saitama – ‘One Punch Man’

Saitama One Punch Man
Saitama One Punch Man

In ‘One Punch Man’, Saitama stands out with his singular ability to vanquish any foe with one punch. However, this super strength could also be his downfall. His strength, while initially intriguing, quickly devolves into predictability due to the lack of challenging opponents. His character fails to evolve meaningfully, leaving him a stagnant figure in an otherwise vibrant universe.

3. Naruto Uzumaki – ‘Naruto’

Naruto Uzumaki
Naruto Uzumaki

As the titular character of the globally popular Naruto series, Naruto Uzumaki has undeniably left a significant imprint on the anime world. Yet, he’s subject to criticism for his repetitive story arc and his tendency to overshadow other potentially fascinating characters.

Despite his remarkable powers, Naruto’s overdependence on the Nine-Tails chakra and shadow clones detracts from the depth of his character.

4. Izuku Midoriya (Deku) – ‘My Hero Academia’

Izuku Midoriya
Izuku Midoriya

Izuku Midoriya, also known as Deku, begins ‘My Hero Academia’ as an underdog who, through a twist of fate, inherits a potent Quirk from his idol. Unfortunately, Deku’s character progression is hindered by his lack of distinctive personality traits and slow character development. This, combined with his unearned Quirk, places him in the list of overrated anime characters.

5. Chrollo Lucilfer – ‘Hunter X Hunter’

Chrollo Lucilfer

Chrollo Lucilfer, a formidable antagonist in ‘Hunter X Hunter’, leads the notorious band of thieves, Phantom Troupe. Although his power to steal and use others’ Nen abilities is a unique twist, it can also cheapen the tension in battle sequences. Moreover, his character lacks progression, making him less appealing in the long run.

6. Edward – ‘Cowboy Bebop’

Edward Wong Cowboy Bebop

Edward Wong, a whiz-kid hacker from ‘Cowboy Bebop’, delivers comic relief and valuable intel for the Bebop crew. However, her character lacks the complexity and development of her fellow main characters. Furthermore, she contributes little to the series’ existential and darker themes, making her an incongruous and overrated character in an otherwise mature narrative.

7. Sosuke Aizen – ‘Bleach’

Sosuke Aizen

As a chief antagonist in ‘Bleach’, Sosuke Aizen initially presents as a compelling villain. However, his vague motives and lack of personal relationships result in a shallow and unengaging character. Without any meaningful redemption or remorse, Aizen’s character falls flat.

8. Kirito – ‘Sword Art Online’


Kirito, the protagonist of ‘Sword Art Online’, is a gamer trapped in a perilous virtual world. While his extraordinary gaming skills and leadership are initially compelling, they soon become unrealistic due to the lack of challenges and hardships. This inconsistency and poorly explained motivations make Kirito an overrated character.

9. Monkey D. Luffy – ‘One Piece’

Monkey D. Luffy

Monkey D. Luffy, the captain of the Straw Hat Pirates in ‘One Piece’, is a beloved character with a straightforward dream. However, his repetitive story arc and predictability can make his character seem uninspired and overhyped.

10. Eren Yeager – ‘Attack on Titan’

Eren Yeager

Eren Yeager, the lead character of ‘Attack on Titan’, carries an inflexible goal fueled by anger and impulsiveness. While contributing to his character growth, these traits also paint him as reckless and single-minded, leading some to categorize him as an overrated character.


The debate over the overrated nature of characters is highly subjective and depends on individual preferences and interpretations. While some might see the flaws in these characters as signs of overrating, others might view them as elements that add depth and humanity to the characters, making them relatable and, in turn, popular.

Therefore, it’s important to remember that the discussions around these characters contribute to the diversity and richness of the anime community, promoting a deeper appreciation of this creative medium.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes an anime character overrated?

An overrated anime character often receives excessive praise or attention despite having noticeable flaws, lack of development, or poor character progression.

Are all the main characters in anime overrated?

No, not all main characters in anime are overrated. While some protagonists may receive criticism for lack of development or predictability, others are celebrated for their complexity, growth, and distinctiveness.

Can a character be overrated and popular at the same time?

Yes, a character can be overrated and popular simultaneously. Popularity often contributes to an overrated character, as their mass appeal can overshadow any flaws or lack of development

Leave a Comment